RSS Feed for this Blog

Monday, June 05, 2006

Big Carrots and Belmont Notes

- Barbaro chomped "phenomenally large" carrots as a wide-open field of 12 takes shape for the Belmont. Steve Crist says don’t bother to start scouring musty chart books from decades past to find a weaker Belmont lineup.

How about going back a mere 52 weeks?
......
There's no one in this year's field who appears remotely as talented as Afleet Alex, but there's no evidence that Giacomo is any better than half of this year's lineup. Last year's Belmont had four graded-stakes winners, while this one has five. Last year's field had just three runners (Afleet Alex, Giacomo, and Reverberate) who had ever run a Beyer Speed Figure of 98 or better, while this year's has seven - High Finance (103), Bob and John (102), Deputy Glitters (102), Sunriver (102), Bluegrass Cat (101), Sacred Light (99), and Steppenwolfer (98). [Daily Racing Form]
Jazil, High Finance, Sunriver, and Bluegrass Cat are all scheduled to work out on Monday morning. Dan Pietz is hoping that Steppenwolfer is OK after his six furlong work in 1:10 1/5 on Friday.
“The fast work was probably a combination of a fast track and him working well. If you saw him do it, you would have thought he went in 1:14.”

Although Peitz said Steppenwolfer looked fine, he won’t know what impact the work had until the colt goes back to the track to train.

“I’m expecting him to be good when he goes back to the track,” Peitz said. “I’ll probably jog him a couple miles tomorrow, unless the track is real sloppy, then we’d probably shedrow him.” [NYRA]
Team Valor purchased Oh So Awesome because they figured that the crop was a weak one and that the Belmont would be up for grabs. Though I’m sure they weren’t figuring on the eventual turn of events to make that so, they are right where they want to be. Barry Irwin told the Thoroughbred Times: "I've seen worse Belmonts for sure, but there's not anything in there that will scare anyone away." [Thoroughbred Times] He closed well enough for third in his Belmont debut to, I suppose, make him a viable candidate here.

NYRA VP Bill Nader maintains that "I think 60,000 is a realistic number for the Belmont Stakes Day attendance." [Albany Times-Union] With no horses with any real star power, NYRA is emphasizing the tradition of the race in its print ads, with pictures of Secretariat’s romp, Affirmed and Alydar’s duel, and a picture of our own trainer, Billy Turner in reference to Seattle Slew. They’re also reminding us that admission is “only $5.” That’s half of the price last year, but still more than the usual $2 grandstand admission. But the alcohol ban is still in effect, at the request of the NYPD and Nassau County police, according to.....Nader. [NY Post] I make the over-under 54,000.

- Attima took all the money for the G2 Honeymoon BC Handicap at Hollywood Sunday, and coasted home to a win at 4-5 over the previously-undefeated-in-the-US Foxysox. Take a look at the past performances, and you’ll see another example, as with the male division in the Shoemaker last week, of horses with very ordinary form in Europe moving to the fore of their divisions over here. Attima, by the Gone West stallion Zafonic, could do no better than third in three tries against graded company in France, but now moves on the the G1 Hollywood Oaks Invitational, for which she earns an automatic bid. Maybe. "The Oaks is in just 25 days," [trainer Julio Canani] told TVG, citing several other races later in the season. "That's not enough time. The first thing to me is the animal." [Bloodhorse]

Foxysox, winless in five races in the UK, suffered her first loss in her fifth start here.

Sunday, June 04, 2006

Odds and Ends - June 4

- Todd Pletcher sent out first-timer Scat Daddy (Johannesburg) on Saturday at Belmont; this was the horse that John Velazquez was supposed to return on at Monmouth on Friday; but he was scratched that day. He was bet down to .65-to-1, and won by five. Of the eight first-time two year-olds that Pletcher has run at the Belmont and Churchill meetings, six have won, and the other two ran second. Scat Daddy won so easily that the chart caller was moved to note that “he was gone before the whip was turned over.” I’m anxious to see how they translate that one for the comment line in the Form.

Johannesburg (Hennessy) had his first winner the other day in the UK; and I believe that Scat Daddy is his first one in the U.S. Scat Daddy is out of a Mr. Prospector mare, and is, in fact, inbred 4x2 to that stallion. The broodmare, Love Style, is a half-sister to the nice turf horse Grat. Scat Daddy's second dam is the G1 (Las Virgenes) winner Likeable Style.

- Hey, Christening (Vicar) is entered in the first race at Delaware on Tuesday! She’s in for a $40,000 tag and has Ramon Dominguez up to ride for Graham Motion; doesn't get much better than that at Delaware. The hope is that she’ll run well and get sold. If she doesn’t get claimed. The word is that we think she should be “very competitive” in this spot.

- Kiaran Fallon dismissed speculation that he was unhappy with the decision to let Horatio Nelson start in the Epsom Derby. (I should actually say the Vodophone Derby. We’re unhappy about adding ‘Presented by Yum’ to the Kentucky Derby...they apparently sold out the entire name of the race.)

"I just felt that he was a little bit flat - he wasn't giving the same bounce that he had done...”

"But he was fine when I trotted him up and down a few times, in fact the more I trotted him the better he felt.

"I was happy with him. If I wasn't happy then I wouldn't have gone round on him.

"He travelled brilliantly on the snaff in the race then we went to go and challenge and it happened. Obviously it must have been one of the uneven bits of ground that you can get on the camber at Epsom. He twisted a joint and that did it.” [Sporting Life]
- Mike Hushion sent out My Little Bean (David) in the 4th at Belmont Sunday; in her only prior race, in February, this three year-old NY bred was 4-1 in a 12 horse field, but ran a distant 5th after a bad start. On Sunday, she was 4-1 morning line, and was hanging around 7-2 with a few minutes to go. The late money came in on this one in abundance folks; she went from 3-1 to 5-2 to 2-1 in the last two flashes. (Again, odds with three minutes to go is something I'd love to see in race charts and past performances.) But she was a bit slow away from the gate again, and never threatened in rallying for third behind the favorite Mrs. Chippy in the six furlong affair.

My Little Bean was running very well at the finish though, and was past the winner shortly passed the wire. She continued to gallop out strongly around the sweeping Belmont turn, and jockey Pedro Morales needed outrider assistance to pull her up. Definitely one to watch on the stretch out and/or on a wet surface.

Saturday, June 03, 2006

Bad and Good On Display

- Gary Stevens told us all to keep our chins up after the ultimately fatal injury to Horatio Nelson this morning on TVG, assuring us that there would still be great racing to come. They seemed like hollow words at the time. Barbaro’s injury didn’t scream ‘fatal’ to me in its immediate aftermath. I suppose the book is still considered to be ‘out’ as to whether I was right. But this one left no doubt and it was truly devastating. Frank Lyons warned that we might want to turn away as they showed the replay, and I wish I’d heeded his advice; you could practically hear the snap just from seeing the violence of the breakdown. And of course, there was the sense that the whole thing could have been avoided.

But as the day went on, Stevens was right - there was some tremendous racing to come. Life, and racing, go on, and unfortunately, there’s a price to be paid for the endless hours of joy that we all derive from the mysteries and triumphs that the game provides us. I’m interested to see if the reaction differs over there – already I’ve noticed a distinct lack of trying to blame someone for allowing the horse to run. The account in the UK’s TimesOnline merely notes that he was observed and “passed fit.” Trying to find fault seemed to be the first reaction over here after the Preakness, and I for one am interested to see whether that’s the case over there.

In fact, I wonder if there’s going to be much reaction at all. If you go to the Racing Post home page, the big story is undoubtedly Sir Percy, and Horatio Nelson is a secondary story. Over here, we didn't start to hear about Bernardini until Tuesday or so.

But getting back to the great racing, let’s start with the Opening Verse at Churchill, where it was Rush Bay (Cozzene) making it two in a row after his disappointing four-year old debut. I was all over him that time, and touted him here. I just missed his subsequent race; I guess I wasn’t enthused enough about his 4th place finish to bother putting him on my watch list. In this race, I went instead for 9-2 Free Thinking, who got the lead and set a slow pace. But Rush Bay, closer to the pace once again, was right behind, and after putting my choice away, had to contend with the even money favorite, Purim. It looked like Purim was going to pass him around the sixteenth pole, but Rush Bay resisted and prevailed in a dramatic stretch duel.

[Aaccording to the race chart, Purim “appeared to be struck in the face by the whip of RUSH BAY’s rider nearing the sixteenth pole." As far as I know, that’s supposed to be an automatic DQ. No mention of that in the Form or Bloodhorse stories, and watching the replay was inconclusive from the pan shot.]

It’s the first stakes winner of the year for Cozzene, who is a career 8% stakes winners-from-foals sire.

Another fantastic finish in the G2 Milady at Hollywood. Patrick Valenzuela rode Proposed on the lead as if he had the measure of 9-1 Somethingaboulaura even as he was tugged to a 45.75-second first half, and started to edge away from that rival going into the turn. But Valenzuela seemed to be taken by surprise when Victor Espinoza drove Somethingaboutlaura past him. "I beat that other filly sprinting and I thought she'd [fade] quicker than she did." [Daily Racing Form] From there, they were neck and neck down the stretch, and when Proposed was finally able to open a late lead, she then had to hold off the late charge of the even money favorite Star Parade, doing so by a lunging head. A little consolation for her sire, Benchmark, given Brother Derek’s unsuccessful Triple Crown campaign.

And then there was Lost in the Fog. The skeptics were ready to pounce, and even some of the believers may have wavered had he failed to respond here. But it was a performance far more typical of the ones that earned him the Eclipse. He was able to sit behind Exciting Metro for a quarter mile, buried that one with a second quarter burst, then laid down the gauntlet with an impressive eighth of 11.29 seconds when Kelly’s Landing loomed at the top of the stretch, and got home a length and a quarter in front in a final time of 1:08.52 (final eighth of 12.16). Russell Baze said "I didn't move him or anything, just let him run his race." [Thoroughbred Times]

Lost in the Fog is a horse with a little panache, and one that seems to get people talking, and that’s a good thing. He beat a nice horse in Kelly’s Landing – he won this race last year with a 112 Beyer – but I don’t think he did anything that will convince his skeptics, and the debates are sure to continue. However, he's definitely back; the Smile Sprint Handicap at Calder could be his next race.

Horatio Nelson Euthanized

- The injuries to Horatio Nelson turned out to be fatal.

There was damage to the ligaments and nerves around the horse's joints and with open wounds, which could already have been infected, there was a unanimous decision taken by the five vets present that it was a hopeless case and it was in the horse's best interests to put him down. [Sporting Life]
Regarding the pre-race examination of the horse, all I’m reading thus far is an official statement to the effect that "The veterinary surgeon and the trainer agreed that they were satisfied that Horatio Nelson was fit to compete." I imagine we’ll be hearing more about that.

I think it’s fair to say, however, that here in the post-Barbaro era, Horatio Nelson would not have started if he was racing in this country. No connection between anything that happened before the start of the Preakness and the injury to Barbaro has been established. Yet enough attention was paid to the debate so that I believe that we’ll be seeing a more cautious attitude, at least for the foreseeable future.

The official statement from the UK’s Horseracing Regulatory Authority added that: "The trainer and the vet at the start, Jenny Hall, discussed the way the horse was moving.” I think that any horse that even just gets to that stage here will not compete in the race, especially in a big stakes.

Epsom Derby Another Big Bummer

- Another potential black eye for the sport this morning, as Horatio Nelson, the second choice for the Epsom Derby, broke down gruesomely during the stretch run after the TV cameras showed jockey Kiaran Fallon consulting with a track steward and trainer Aidan O’Brian just prior to the race. Excellent job on TVG spotting this before the race (it actually was a phone call by Gary Stevens that alerted them to what was going on); the word was that the horse could be scratched, and the start was delayed for a couple of minutes.

After the race, TVG showed replays that clearly showed that the horse was badly washed out as Fallon spoke with O’Brian and seemed to jog the horse away from the rest of the field as if to test him. Unfortunately, he was not scratched. (Stevens explained that it’s very difficult to get horses scratched under these circumstances there, adding that monies wagered with bookies at the racetrack would not be refunded once they are placed.) Horses very rarely break down on the grass in Europe according to Lyons and Stevens, so it will be interesting to see the reaction in the UK. We read last week that British TV wouldn’t even carry replays of Barbaro’s breakdown, and this accident was far more difficult to watch.

It was a rousing finish, as Sir Percy squeezed up the rail and got his nose down right at the wire to just nail maiden longshot Dragon Dancer, with pacesetter Dylan Thomas hanging on for third. The best horse in the race, however, may have been the 4th place finisher Hala Bek, whose rally was badly interrupted by him bearing out badly in deep stretch, before recovering and re-rallying to miss the whole thing by probably around ¼ of a length.

Amazing finish, but as in the Preakness, the race itself will be overshadowed by the breakdown of Horatio Nelson and the inevitable finger-pointing regarding what happened before the race, and why he was permitted to run.

Lost in the Fog Needs Clarity

- This is a must-win for Lost in the Fog today in the G3 Aristides Breeders Cup at Churchill. We can give him the first-off-the-layoff excuse in his Golden Gate debut in April, coming as it did against a very sharp sprinter in Charthage (who will run at Bay Meadows on Sunday). There’s nobody as good as that one in here; none of these horses (including Lost in the Fog for that matter) have cracked triple Beyer digits in their last two races. Greg Gilchrist expects a better effort today.

"With all the build-up and expectations, I didn't want to flat out say the horse was going to run bad but I made it clear [the Golden Gate Sprint] wasn't going to be his best race. Sure enough, three days later he was dead lame. He had a big bruise in one foot. So it was there, we took care of it and, overall, I'm sure he's a much fitter horse than he was six weeks ago." [FOX Sports]
Three other stakes on the Churchill card, as the Kentucky track and Belmont will trade big weekend for the next three weeks (Belmont Stakes next week, Stephen Foster the following).

- Nice allowance win for Rathor at Belmont on Friday, and Bobby Frankel has bigger goals in mind for the four-year old son of Machiavellian. "If he runs really well, he could come back in the Suburban,” Frankel said earlier in the week. He ran really well; in fact, it was closer to a public workout as Elbar Coa never even thought about going to the whip, and was able to gear the horse down near the wire. He’s now undefeated in three races on the dirt here after coming over from the UK.

- Steppenwolfer had a huge workout on Friday, getting six furlongs in 1:10.36.
Belmont clockers timed Steppenwolfer in fractions of 12.16 seconds, 24.00, 35.65, and 47.06. Steppenwolfer galloped out seven furlongs in 1:23.73 and continued out a mile in 1:37.62.

Castillo wasn't pushing on the horse, and the horse was not blowing back at the barn.

"He did it in a way that left my mouth open,'' Castillo said. [Daily Racing Form]
Dan Pietz said that the colt hadn’t worked so quickly since his work for the two-year old sale that he topped at $375,000, and reader Marc asks “How good would Steppenwolfer be if he hadn't been cranked up for a 2-yr-old sale?” Perhaps we’ll find out next Saturday. We don’t generally see the Belmont won in the last-to-first fashion that one would associate with Steppenwolfer, but perhaps he’ll be closer to the pace this time. "I think he has more natural speed than what he shows in the afternoon," Peitz said. [Bloodhorse]

- John Velazquez returned to the races with a win at Belmont on Friday, guiding Pletcher’s Mr. Sam I Am to a win in the 4th race. He was supposed to ride at Monmouth, but appeared at Belmont instead, and just like that, it was ‘thanks, see ya’ for Garrett Gomez, who was originally named to ride. It seemed like a major sucker bet, as Mr. Sam I Am was sent off at 6-5 despite having never run on the turf. But sentiment got the better of logic in this case, and it was a triumphant return for the rider, who was out since April 13, when he suffered injuries - a fractured collarbone, partially collapsed lung, torn shoulder ligaments and bruised ribs - that would have many of us still lying in bed watching TVG.

Friday, June 02, 2006

Odds and Ends - June 2

- It's not often that you see a horse appear in a $14,000 claiming race after having last run second in a Grade 2 stakes. But that was the case today with Willy o'the Valley, back to the races nearly 11 months after his close second to Smokume in the Tom Fool. Two races before that, he won the G3 Maryland BC Handicap.

But there he was today for Richard Dutrow, and the bettors were somewhat skeptical, making him at .95-to-1 favorite against what was, at least on paper, a hopelessly overmatched field. Horsemen were downright dubious, as nobody put in a claim. I was thinking you gotta bet against him, but fortunately none of the others inspired me to do so.

Willy o'the Valley (Will's Way) won pretty handily, tracking the leaders before moving three wide around the turn and drawing away. However, remember we were talking about Joe Takach and bad pull-ups the other day, and Willy o'the Valley did not gallop-out well at all. He barely made it to the far turn (which is longer at Belmont than most, but still...) and walked back very slowly. He didn't even stick around for the winners' circle photo, as the owners gathered awkwardly around jockey Rudy Rodriguez.

Then, in a macabre coincidence, Papa Behr (Behrens), a three-year old half brother to Willy O'the Valley making his debut for a $35,000 tag, pulled up shortly after the start and was vanned off.

- Great stretch drive in the Coronation Cup, as Ouija Board made a run at Shirocco midstretch. But the BC Turf champ dug in, repelled the mare's charge, and went on to a 1 3/4 length win. Shirocco is now two-for-two since returning for his five year old campaign last month; in his last, he earned a 130+ Timeform rating which was by far and away the best in the field, and which, if you use the 14 point rule of thumb in comparing the numbers to Beyers, compares quite favorably to Grade 1 turf horses running here. Ouija Board's trainer Ed Dunlop said: "She has been beaten by probably one of the best horses in the world and I am thrilled with her." [Sporting Life]

In the Epsom Oaks, Alexandrova (Sadler's Wells) drew off to win easily in the mile and a half race, as, in the words of the UK's Guardian Unlimited site, came with an irresistible run on the outside and made mincemeat of the opposition.

It was instructive to look at the past performances of these races (good job by the Form, and by TVG for carrying them live). There's a big deal being made about the spacing of the Triple Crown races, but it's interesting to see how two week gaps between races are commonplace in Europe. The Oaks winner made her first start since September on May 17, and then came back to run a mile and a half just 16 days later. French entry Galatee had started before on 4/22, 5/7, and 5/17. Runner-up Rising Cross had run a week apart on 4/1 and 4/8, and again on 5/6 before this race today. And these are three-year old fillies.

On the other hand, they do seem to take more time off between campaigns over there, and don't prep as much for the classics. And they run on turf. If it turns out that Polytrack allows horses to come back quicker here, it would serve the sport very well.

- The Epsom Derby will be on TVG at 8:20 A.M. Eastern time tomorrow morning.

News and Notes - June 2

- Bellamy Road recorded a three furlong work in a reported 40 seconds at George Steinbrenner’s Kinsman Farm; that's the first reported work I've seen for him.

Discreet Cat zipped a half in 48.01 (2/35) at Belmont.

Declan's Moon continues his comeback with a five furlong work in 59.80 (3/20) at Santa Anita. "He looks awesome," [trainer Ron] Ellis said. "He might be a better horse now than before."

Though many of us are still suffering from the Barbaro Blues, hey, there's plenty of potential for a fabulous fall. Imagine a Breeders Cup Classic with Bernardini, Discreet Cat, Declan's Moon, Bellamy Road, Brother Derek, Lava Man, Buzzards Bay, Eloctrocutionist, Commentator, Surf Cat, Flower Alley..... The possibilities seem endless. Unfortunately, so is the list of things that can go wrong.

- Mike Trombetta told the NY Post that Sweetnorthernsaint is still “pretty tender” after grabbing a quarter in the Preakness. “The Travers is a definite possibility."

Oh So Awesome worked seven furlongs in 1:27.4 at Belmont, and Hemingway’s Key went five in 1:01.29 on the Saratoga training track. Zito likes to train his horses up there, as does John Ward, who sent Minister’s Bid out to work the same distance in the day’s fastest 1:00.35.

- NYRA met with the horsemen at Belmont yesterday, and highlighted the fact that daily average handle on NYRA's races has increased by 4.7 percent, and daily average ontrack handle has increased by 7.7 percent in 2006. The increase was partly attributed to the new Rewards rebate program, which has returned around $60,000 to bettors since Belmont opened.

Another reason given for the increase is bigger fields, and that actually is a cause for concern for some of the horsemen. The larger fields are partly due to the increase in NY-bred races, and that doesn’t work for trainers such as Todd Pletcher or Bobby Frankel, who have been frustrated this summer by races failing to fill.

While both men attended Thursday's meeting, neither spoke. Pletcher did talk privately with Hayward and Duncker afterward.

"I wanted to make sure they're aware that Belmont and Saratoga need to be treated differently than winter racing at Aqueduct," Pletcher said.

Hayward admitted that racing secretary P.J. Campo has been instructed to use races with bigger fields, but added that he needs to be flexible.

"P.J.'s instructions are to maximize field size and to run competitive racing," Hayward said. "But he's got to feel empowered that when he has a five-horse field, to let that race go rather than go with a claimer with 10 or 12 horses." [Daily Racing Form]
The construction of the Aqueduct casino, amazingly, STILL has not begun, and NYRA VP Bill Nader said that the State Lottery is still two weeks away from issuing final approval, and that "that construction will start at Aqueduct before the racing shifts to Saratoga on July 26." [NY Daily News] Assuming that the construction will take at least a year, the revenue will barely be starting to flow before NYRA’s franchise expires at the end of next year. And how NYRA will make it financially that long remains to be seen, as their bailout loan was only intended to help them make it through the end of this year.

- Brad Free warns us to not overemphasize the Beyer figures of first time two-year old starters.
It is an easy trap with 2-year-olds, who often make quantum leaps on the Beyer scale in their second start.

Regardless of workouts, pedigree, or trainer, there is nothing like initial race experience to wake up a 2-year-old. It happens every spring, and has already begun with these second-time starters at Hollywood:

* Swiss Rose ($12) won May 24. Her Beyer jumped from 46 to 73.
* Herb's Girl Kelsey ($6.20) won May 25. Her Beyer jumped from 35 to 54.
* Little City ($12.20) won May 25. Her Beyer jumped from 59 to 87.
* Doubloon City ($5.20) won May 25. Her Beyer jumped from 48 to 79.
* Diamond Dave ($4.40) won May 29; his Beyer jumped from 56 to 85.

None ran fast in their debut. But a soft figure is not the end of the world for a 2-year-old first-time starter. [Daily Racing Form]

Chula!

- Las Vegas gambling giant Boyd Gambling has purchased Dania Jai-Alai and 50 surrounding acres for $152.2 million. The facility was the only one of the four Broward County pari-mutuels that had not announced lavish expansion plans to go along with the slot machines that are expected to go online later this year.

''We want Dania to be a first-class entertainment facility,'' said Steve Snyder, president of The Aragon Group, which has owned the fronton for the past 35 years. ``We need expertise and resources that are greater than ours. I always said we'd bring in someone with that expertise.'' [Miami Herald]
The jai-alai players themselves were said to be “leery” as to the company’s intentions, and who can blame them? Boyd is obviously not there to yell “CHULA!” The sport has been dying a slow death, and there’s either five or six active frontons remaining in this country, depending on which account one reads. However, the company met with the players to assure them that jai-alai will remain “part of the showcase of their facility.”
Players, who currently make between $40,000 and $65,000 a year, agreed to a new contract with the owners of Dania that allows them a $15,000 to $20,000 bonus at the end of the year. That figure would escalate, according to Irusta, depending on the growth of jai-alai and revenue once slots are installed. [Sun-Sentinal]
And here’s the “I remember when” part of this post, as I spent a fair amount of time at Dania during visits to Florida back in the late 70’s; and the place was really hopping, even for the weekday matinees.

It did always seem kind of strange, though, making pari-mutuel wagers on a sport featuring strictly humans. The possibility for chicanery is just so obvious. No drugging nor elaborate conspiracies are necessary; just a simple drop of the ball will do. The idea of betting on animals seemed somehow more reliable. Still, it is an exciting game, and the atmosphere was electric. Perhaps Boyd can use the fact that it’s become such an rarity amongst the vast selection of gambling options to market it as a unique night out, and breathe a little life into it. If they really do care about it, that is.

- In April, Harrah’s donated $500,000 to the Pennsylvania Harness Racing Commission to help increase purses for four Sire Stakes races this year. They claimed that they were being “good citizens,” and that it had nothing to do with the fact that they are one of the competitors for a lucrative stand-alone casino license for Pittsburgh.

But now, in Illinois, Harrah’s is one of four casino companies that have filed suit against the state over a new law that would require them to give 3% of their gross earnings, an estimated $36 million annually, to the tracks.
The horse-racing industry is supposed to give $20 million to breeders and horse owners in the form of larger racing purses, and the other $16 million is to be used to upgrade tracks and market the industry. [Chicago Tribune]
In 1999, a law granted benefits, such as dockside gaming, to the riverboat casinos, in return for subsidies that the racing industry was to receive from what was supposed to be the tenth casino in the state. However, that casino never was built, and this new law is merely intended to compensate the racing industry for that loss of income. Wagering on horse racing in Illinois has decreased by 42% from $835 million to $482 million since the first riverboat casino opened in 1992. Besides Harrah’s, Penn National, owner of two of the other affected casinos (only the four largest, of the nine in the state, are subject to the fee) is involved in the suit as well. This is all something to keep in mind the next time a casino company – even ones that currently own racetracks – tell you just how much they care about the sport.

Wednesday, May 31, 2006

Early Pletcher Double

- Interesting maiden special turf race in the first at Belmont on Thursday. Morning line favorite Brantley (3-1) was bet down to favoritism in her debut on May 7, and I posted about the race here. She had to try and circle the field coming into the stretch and was a good four wide, but continued on gamely for third behind the impressive winner Beautiful Danielle, and Judith Basin, who is also in the field. However, the latter moves from the two hole out to post nine, while Brantley starts for the second time from the eight post. Brantley is by the turf champ Theatrical, out of the graded stakes winning mare Biogio’s Rose (Polish Numbers).

Eden’s Causeway (Giant’s Causeway) has been a big money burner, going down at 4-1 and 3-2 twice. The half-brother to Paradise Creek and Wild Event will likely get bet down again, and looks like a bet-against, at least in the win pool.

And it could be a short-priced Pletcher double with Audacious Chloe, the 3-5 morning line favorite against just four other two-year olds. You may recall that she looked home free in her debut at 3-5 at Keeneland, but succumbed late to 24-1 Pro Pink. The latter subsequently ran second against the boys just eight days later in the G3 Kentucky Breeders Cup at Churchill, this time at 23-1.

Stanley Hough, 19% with first-time two-year olds over the last five years, sends out his first one of the year in Velvet Charm. She’s by Montbrook, out of an On To Glory mare; she’s a half to the Florida stakes winner Royal Lad.

Sucker Bets

- Joe Takach has been writing about “physicality handicapping,” the art of interpreting the body language of the horse, for many years. In fact, somewhere in a box in my house somewhere I have an old VCR tape of his about what to look for in the paddock and on the track before the race.

Besides my lousy money management, an inability to avoid getting distracted by simulcasts, a tendency to space out, indecisiveness, a general lack of courage of my convictions, paying too much attention to the tote board, drinking too much (at all, actually), and my penchant for leaving the track with less money than I came with, physicality handicapping is the weakest part of my game. I must admit that I sometimes fall into the category of Takach’s Sucker Bets – Part 14 - BETTING A HORSE WITHOUT WATCHING THE POST PARADE - part of a continuing series he’s doing for John Pricci’s Theyareatthepost.com.

In order to avoid this “sucker bet” you must believe that horses are warm-blooded athletes rather than lifeless machines and you have to get your face out of the past performances long enough to view your potential wager.
He points out that simulcasts offer the “5 second glimpse,” which Takach feels is usually enough. He lists seven specific things to look out for, so check out the column in its entirety.

The work doesn’t end once the race is over either. Takach publishes the Daily Southern California Horses To Watch (SCHTW), and chief among his observations are the gallop-outs - and the return to the front of the track for unsaddling - following the race. Sucker Bets – Part 10 is betting a horse that PULLS UP POORLY IN THE POST-RACE.
A normal post-race warm-down at the conclusion of a race is a slowing from a gallop to a slow canter that continues to the backstretch with a turnaround at the 5/8 or 9/16 pole (mile track). The runner is then slowly cantered back for unsaddling. If there are no major post-race negative observations, the horse is said to come out of his race in “good order”.

Just as a horse needs a proper pre-race warm-up to maximize potential in his upcoming race, so too does he need a proper warming down in the post-race. This helps the runner to cool out properly when returned to the backside and avoid any unnecessary muscle soreness that could last into his next outing.

Anything less than this proper gallop-out would be considered a bad pull-up of some kind. Bad post-race pull-ups are very bad next out wagers regardless of whether the horse was pulled up prematurely by a lazy jockey or he’s pulled up too quickly because of injury or an aggravation of a prior injury.
Of course, there are different degrees of bad pull-ups, ranging from the worst, being eased or the “quick pull-up” - at a dead stop within 100 yards past the finish line (kinda reminds me of “Mission Accomplished”), to an OK gallop-out but a slow walk back.

All of them are bad bets according to Takach; he cites a 2003 SCHTW study which showed that only 9.1% of bad pull-ups won their next out at Del Mar, 9.8% at Santa Anita, stats which I suspect are not as astounding as they may seem. I don’t always mean to make things complicated, but statistics in sports without an appropriate reference is one of my real pet peeves. To me, it’s meaningless that, in a hypothetical example, the Buffalo Sabres won 30 out of 35 games in which they led going into the third period unless I also know what the league-wide average is. Learning the Green Bay Packers’ third down efficiency on 3th and more than 5 begs the question of how the rest of the league does in that same situation.

Similarly, what percentage of the bad pull-ups finished their race in such a manner that you wouldn’t bet him based on the past performances anyway? Please correct me if I’m wrong, but my guess would be that that number is pretty high. A more meaningful stat to me would be the percentage of bad pull-ups who won or finished within a certain number of lengths behind the winner failed to win their next race. Sorry for making it more complicated than it should be; I just can’t help myself. In any event, Takach has some interesting things to say and the series is worth checking out; though some of his sucker bets, like “Won With a Dream Trip Last Out” are rather obvious.

Belmont Notes - May 31

- Sweetnorthernsaint is out of the Belmont, and that seems like a sensible move. He’s yet to show he can win beyond nine furlongs, and he’s had a pretty long campaign. But he better rest up while he can, because it sounds as if he won’t have too much time off.

The first major goal, Trombetta said, will be either the Grade 1, $1 million Haskell Invitational at Monmouth Park, or the Grade 3, $750,000 West Virginia Derby at Mountaineer. Both are on Aug. 6.

"I'd like to run him once before then in July," Trombetta said. [Daily Racing Form]
Bob and John (Seeking the Gold) is working lights out in California for the Belmont, and I’d prefer he stay there. It takes a little time for me to get over my animosity towards a horse who, after I pick him to win the Derby in print for scores of readers, runs 17th. But at the same time, there’s also kind of a bond – after all, years from now, long after I’ve forgotten the names of every other horse in the race, I’ll still be able to recall “Yes, I had Bob and John that year. He ran 17th” – and an insistent urge to bet him again. It doesn’t help when you read his jockey excuse the Derby:
"I'm definitely drawing a line through the race," Gomez said. "He's a big colt. He kept getting knocked around the whole time. He got slammed going to the wire the first time, got slammed around the first turn. I finally had him moving forward with some nice progress - I was liking my chances at the half-mile pole - and I had a horse run into my hind inside quarter. [It] completely turned him sideways and he just quit." [DRF]
Baffert said: "He's got the right style for that race.....He's big, with a high cruising speed." His latest work was a bullet (of 22) six furlongs in 1:12.20 at Santa Anita. Don’t get me started...

HC Update

- Bill Turner will eschew the sensible advice given by a recent commenter, and run Highland Cat in a maiden special. “Bill feels confident that HC can run against the big boys after seeing him race last time out on the grass, coming in second.” No word as of yet on what kind of distance he’ll be looking for.

Christening had her second workout since she ‘tied up’ last month, and, like the first one, it was pretty leisurely; a half in 51.20 (33/41) down at Delaware. Not likely she’s going to get sold off of works like that.

Notes - May 31

- Walter admonished us for not discussing the Shoemaker, and it was a Grade 1 after all, so I guess we should mention it. Once the racing starts to really pick up here in New York after a long, cold winter on the inner track, it’s easy to forget that there’s important racing going on elsewhere. Winner Aragorn was the longest shot on the board at 6.50 to 1 despite three close seconds and a win in his last four starts, and a 108 Beyer two races back that was tied for the highest in the field. He stalked Willow O’Wisp, who absolutely walked through a first half of 47.88, which enabled him to sprint home in 45 seconds; with a final quarter of 22.22 and a last eighth of 11.23! Wow! Jockey Corey Nakatani stated the obvious when he said: "I could tell that he was full of run. When I asked him the question to kick on, he did." [LA Daily News] Second place finisher Charmo obviously did quite well to rally for that placing.

Aragorn is by Giant’s Causeway, and it seems to me that he is the first U.S. Grade 1 winner on the turf for the sire. First Samurai won two Grade 1’s – the Hopeful and the Champagne – on the dirt last year. Aragorn is out of a winless Mr. Prospector mare, but his second dam is Savannah Dancer (Northern Dancer), who won graded stakes here on the grass and dirt, and the third dam is the Irish champion Valoris, winner of the Epsom Oaks and Irish 1,000 Guineas.

- Amid the latest theory as to how and why Barbaro got hurt, Edgar Prado visited the stricken Derby champ, and related to the Albany Times-Union just how deeply the injury affected him.

"I really thought about taking some time off.....But I thought it would be very hard for me to stay home and just do a lot of thinking so I went back to riding. It was tough to concentrate but I had to continue to work and move forward."
The latest theory, as posted in the comments section by reader twba, is that Barbaro, when bearing out slightly, was struck on the leg by Brother Derek, who was trying to scramble back from a slow start. I suppose that this may be a more comforting explanation to some, as it would be just a freak accident, and not something that was somehow foretold by the gate incident before the race.

Nor would it be a wider indictment of the sport as a whole for the scheduling of the Triple Crown races or the weakening of the breed. Of course, it doesn’t erase those questions raised either; but perhaps those who are calling for an immediate change in the Triple Crown scheduling will pause to formulate a less emotional response.

I happened to come upon a copy of Conquistador Cielo’s past performances yesterday. Some of us remember as if it wasn’t 24 years ago the way he won the Belmont just five days after winning the Met Mile. But do you recall that he also ran not once, but twice prior to the Met Mile in the month of May alone!? And that was after a race in mid-April. Is it really possible that the breed has become so fragile in such a relatively short period of time? Perhaps....unlike some writers who seem to know for sure despite hardly being experts in horse genetics, I’ll readily admit that I don’t know. But I think I can say that Barbaro, who is bred along more classic lines than many of his more commercially-bred peers, was likely a victim of just plain bad luck that is, as un-politically correct as it is to say these days, just part of the game.

- Bill Finley, on ESPN.com, reveals the cold, hard reality of Sheikh Mohammed’s decision to keep Bernardini out of the Belmont.
Because he is a Grade I winner by a top sire (A.P. Indy), he could be retired tomorrow and still be worth $20 million. Why worry about a $600,000 payday that will do little, if anything, for the horse's stud value? [ESPN.com]
By that logic, why risk racing him again at all? So he could be worth $30 million instead? (And this is not an issue of how little time there is between the Preakness and Belmont, unless the latter is run at Saratoga in August.) Though his plans call for a fall campaign, Finley is no doubt correct when he says that Bernardini will likely make two or three more starts and then be retired to stud after the Breeders' Cup.

Tuesday, May 30, 2006

Belmont In The Bag?

- NYRA should probably update their website, doncha think? I mean, this still appears on the home page!

- Sweetnorthernsaint is still a possibility for the Belmont despite suffering a minor foot injury (grabbed quarter) in the Preakness. "He was a little tender for a day or two but it turned out to be no big deal," Trombetta said. "We need to work him by Saturday. If he doesn't work by Saturday, he won't run in the Belmont." [Albany Times-Union]

Cause To Believe, who seemed to have more backers for the Derby than any 50-1 morning line horse in history (it really was just a bad line by Mike Battaglia, and he went off a far more appropriate 25-1) is back in the picture and is a possibility for Jerry Hollendorfer after a mile work in 1:39 4/5.

It’s funny how some horses will grow in its perceived stature approaching a big race even though he/she hasn’t really done anything of late to warrant it. Often, it’s due to the fact that the horse’s prior effort seems, with time, to grow on people. Sunriver was that horse going into the Derby (which he didn’t get into), and Deputy Glitters seems to be gaining respect going into the Belmont. Now, he’s picked up Edgar Prado as well. On Monday, he worked five furlongs in 1:01 2/5. The work included an unplanned and unidentified workmate from the Bill Mott barn.

Much of the optimism centers on a second and third look at his Derby, in which he finished a respectable 8th despite being wide throughout. Assistant trainer Andy Rehm, sitting in for the suspended Tom Albertrani, said of the effort:

"I think he got a 4 on The Sheets, which was one of the lowest numbers in the race. If we got the same kind of trip Bluegrass Cat got, I think we could have been second. Bluegrass Cat is kind of the same horse as Deputy Glitters, he beat us a length and we beat him a length." [NYRA]
And it was Deputy Glitters who had turned the table on Bluegrass Cat after losing to him. Then came the two efforts that you can excuse – the sloppy Wood, and the Derby.

However, I guess it should be pointed out that not all that much positive has yet to come out of that Wood. Plus, there’s nothing too special about his pedigree – he’s by Deputy Commander, a sire who has fizzled since his much hyped first crop featuring Ten Most Wanted, out of Glitterman, a sprinter whose progeny has an average winning distance of just over six furlongs. Nevertheless, he’ll probably take some money, especially with Prado aboard – a lot of sentimental money there, perhaps - as will plodding types such as Jazil and Steppenwolfer, thus perhaps creating a bit of value on Sunriver, who, in my humble opinion 11 days before the Belmont, appears to have this race absolutely in the bag. No?

- Perhaps one way to tell if the casual racing fans and bettors were turned off by the Preakness is to watch the board for the Belmont. If, for example, Platinum Couple is anything close to the absurd 33-1 he went off in the Preakness, then they're proabably still out there watching and throwing their money away on hopeless longshots.

- Richard Dutrow is in the news today for his Met Mile win with Silver Train, but check out what he’s been doing a bit south of Belmont Park: Dutrow has six wins in seven starts this meet at Monmouth Park, where he has 35 horses stabled. [Asbury Park Press]

Monday, May 29, 2006

Monday Night Notes - May 29

- A quiet Memorial Day weekend for Barbaro, who continues to do extremely well. He’s not out of the woods yet of course, and the doctors maintain that it could be months before they know whether Barbaro will survive. [Bloodhorse]

Meanwhile, the flood of news stories continues. Yet another major piece in the NY Times today, this one requiring merely the free registration. Maybe there is something to this “no such thing as bad publicity” thing. The article today ranks as the second most emailed sports story, behind only the Bobby Bonds news. This piece is by Bill Finley, and it’s a comprehensive look at the relationship, if any, between Barbaro’s false start and the injury. Much of it is a rehash of debates we’ve been hearing for a week. But it includes this fascinating theory by a Dr. Sid Gustafson, a Montana-based veterinarian.

"In regard to the Preakness, as unfortunate as it was, and albeit in retrospect, the examining veterinarian should have scratched Barbaro after he broke out of the gate before the starter began the race......The horse tweaked something somewhere as a result of the tremendous force required to break open the gate, and as a result, he was most likely getting off his front end as Edgar tried to jockey him forward early in the race, a slight asynchrony that ultimately put undue forces on the right hind ankle resulting in the horse's breakdown."

He continued: "The breakout cannot be eliminated as a causal effect in my opinion, and although it may have been coincidental, that is unlikely. But you can imagine the politics of such a veterinary scratch with the Triple Crown at stake, taking the favorite out of the race. The veterinarian's hands were tied, and he/she was by and large prevented from taking the horse out."
Well, it’s not that unusual to see horses break through the gate and then reload and race. So he’s really saying that any horse that breaks through the gate should be scratched due to a risk of overcompensating for some likely tweak caused by the act of exerting enough force to open the gate. Seems like a reasonable idea (though I’d be interested to see some statistics supporting his idea – exactly how many horses that break through the gate end up breaking down during the race?), and something concrete that the industry can point to and show that it has learned something from the Preakness. It would likely come to be known as the Barbaro rule.

- Trainer David Donk took the 4th at Belmont on the grass with Tiverton in the gelding’s first race since November. Last week, he sent out Fishy Advice to win on turf off of a similar layoff, and did the same with Peg’s Prayer earlier this month.

The Freakiest Thing Ever

- In the Met Mile, I came up a bit short of what would have been a really nice triple, considering that it paid $190 with Silver Train, the 2-1 favorite, holding off Sun King, who opened at 7-2, but drifted up to 6.90 to 1. I ended up using Silver Train instead of Greeley’s Legacy, who I picked for some minor awards here. For someone who makes most of his decisions within five minutes of post time, I’ve been really good about betting what I pick on this blog, but in this case, I changed my mind. Greeley’s Legacy seemed a bit dead on the board, and I just wasn’t getting positive vibes about him. Bandini looked magnificent in the paddock, but I don’t think this distance and one-turn route is his best game.

It was a frustrating beat for me, and Zito sounded rather flustered as well, referring to some of his recent close calls in a rambling statement.

"It's a little frustrating. In the Donn, we finished second. In the Pimlico Special, we finished second. In the Met Mile we finished second – and we beat (trainer Todd) Pletcher all three times....It's like the freakiest thing ever. The horse ran great. He ran his guts out. This was a tough beat. We lost to the horse that won the Breeders' Cup Sprint over this track. We're there all year in these Grade 1s, we need to win one. I'm grateful to these horses for trying so hard. This race just adds to Sun King's legacy.” [Bloodhorse]
Sun King is growing on me as a racehorse; I was amongst his detractors prior to the Kentucky Derby and I remained skeptical during his brief revival last year. But his last two have been dynamic, and I'm always a sucker for a good closer. However, I wouldn't exactly agree that he has a legacy at this point. For Silver Train, it’s his second major stakes win over a Belmont track over which he’s now four-for-six. Richard Dutrow acknowledged that “If this race were run at Aqueduct or anywhere else in the world, I'm sure he would have gotten beat.” He said that he may point Silver Train to the mile and a quarter Suburban on July 1.

- In the fifth race, a maiden special for three and up, Habsburg (Old Trieste), 5-1 for his debut at Gulfstream for Darley, was 10-1 today, no doubt due to a really nasty past performance line in his only race. He did break poorly that day in April, but showed nothing, fading to 24 lengths behind the winner. This time he broke well, got the lead, and then dug in to repel the Nick Zito-trained Orlov by a neck – another freaky second for Nick! This horse is out of a Nureyev half-sister to Barbican, the Darley colt who was briefly on the Derby Trail before being sidelined with a fractured sesamoid; and also the champion filly Tempera.

All Signs Positive

- Great news from the Billy Turner barn, where Highland Cat is reported to be up and eating well, after being spotted asleep on the floor of his stall on Saturday morning. That initial report gave me a scare, but the latest report is “all signs positive,” and that’s great news. It makes perfect sense that the horse would be tired after really exerting himself for the first time ever; he was really driving at the end to defend his second place finish.

One decision that lies ahead is to whether to move him up in class to maiden specials, or at least a higher claiming price. The thought of him being claimed for $45,000 seemed absurd before Friday’s effort; now, that amount seems way too cheap for a horse with a new lease on life. Highland Cat is eligible to improve after his first attempt on the grass, and, as suggested by a reader here the other day, perhaps a stretch out to one of those 1 3/8 mile maiden special marathons could be to his liking.

Saratoga Preview

- And here they come, down the stretch at Saratoga!



Well, not what one would usually expect. But it is just May, after all. These adorable miniature horses were part of the all-breed show at the Saratoga Bridges Festival and Dressage activities going on there over this Memorial Day weekend. Besides all the cool horses, it was a rare chance to have a look at the track before the crowds descend upon it this August. And I’m very happy to report that absolutely nothing has changed.



Well, actually one thing looked a little different. Lush green grass in the backyard area. This won't last much past the second weekend or the first big storm, whichever comes first.





Bizarre Reporting by Rhoden

- I received some thoughtful comments on my post on the NY Times column by William C. Rhoden last week about the “unknown” filly who died of a heart attack at Belmont on Wednesday. Particularly interesting was the commenter who relates that he/she had been interviewed by Rhoden that day, but that those responses didn’t make it into the piece.

He baited me with the comment that everyone seemed to care about Barbaro, but no one seemed to care about this "anonymous" filly. I told him, "No one cares? I can assure you, sir, that this filly's connections were grief-stricken." He asked who those connections might be. I told him "the assistant trainer and groom ran out there immediately, to be by her side. To the people who spend every day of the week with her, she was as special to them as Barbaro is to the Jacksons".
These remarks obviously didn’t fit into Rhoden’s agenda, and thus ended up on the cutting floor. I had complimented the columnist on at least his reporting skills that were on display, but this revelation shows that he was equally adept at skewing the results of his endeavors towards his point of view (and reader Steve D makes a fair point to the effect that he feels that this is common practice for a newspaper that he, and others, consider to be at the forefront of what they consider to be the liberal media).

On Saturday, Rhoden wrote another column that bashes the industry (again, subscription only, sorry), claiming that in the wake of the Barbaro injury:
..questions have begun to percolate about a bizarre thoroughbred industry, from its training methods to the medication to the routine treatment of horses who aren't superstars.
‘Bizarre?’ That’s a pretty bizarre way in itself to describe a sport that has been part of the mainstream in this country far longer than his beloved basketball has. Rhoden then segues into a discussion of horse slaughter in this country, and here, as opposed to what I considered to be skillful reporting in the prior column, the journalism is shockingly shoddy.

For one thing, he fails to mention that industry groups such as the NTRA and the NYRA have universally supported legislation to ban horse slaughter. Nor does he discuss the numerous private efforts, such as those by organizations such as Old Friends, to find homes for horses after their racing careers. No surprise there.

But worse yet, he writes that: The legislation has been doggedly and successfully fought by cattle associations and veterinarian groups. He never mentions the fact that legislation intended to ban the slaughterhouses was indeed passed by Congress last September. That law attempted to do so by prohibiting federal funding for required inspections of the plants. But the three slaughterhouses circumvented the law by appealing to the Agriculture Department, which subsequently allowed the plants to pay for the inspections themselves. This is one of the examples of the executive branch of the Bush Administration running roughshod over the legislative branch, and perhaps one of the incidents that has contributed to what we can definitely refer to as the "bizarre" sight of Republicans objecting to the recent FBI raid on Democratic Senator William Jefferson’s office. Frankly, I find it rather amazing that a columnist for the so-called Paper of Record would be so negligent with his research.

But despite the shoddy reporting, the column is not completely without its merits. Perhaps you will be as surprised as I am to learn that Dr. Larry Bramlage, the vet who told the Preakness audience on NBC to “say a prayer” for Barbaro, is opposed to current legislative efforts to permanently ban the slaughterhouses.
"We have to have to face the fact that there are unwanted horses, uncared-for horses and neglected horses.....It's a better scenario for the quality of the horse's life to assure that they'll be taken care of and assured that somebody takes the responsibility not to let them suffer. We don't promote the fact that people have to send their horses to slaughter. If there's any other option, we'd prefer they do that."
......
Bramlage described the process by which the horses are slaughtered as instant, humane death. "People think of half-dressed, unshaven people wielding knives," he said. Instead, the slaughterhouses use a bolt gun and a bullet that is on a spring and placed between the horse's eyes and ears. "It shoots out the end and springs back," he said.

This euthanasia system renders the horse instantly unconscious. "You watch the horse, their eyes don't change, they don't even blink and the ears don't even move," Bramlage said. "They drop straight down instantly."
Hopefully, Dr. Bramlage said a prayer for these horses too. His views reflect those of the American Association of Equine Practitioners, of which he is a member. Tom Lenz, a former president of the organization told Rhoden of horses who meet this fate: "They got there because they didn't meet somebody's needs."
Lenz said that those who own horses, those who buy horses and those who breed horses need to do some soul-searching and decide what their motives are for owning a horse and their capabilities of taking care of a horse.

"Outlawing processing is not going to solve the problem," he said.

Maybe not, but it's a start. Eliminate the slaughterhouse.

Let the horse die a natural death.
Now, there’s one thing that we and the columnist for the Times can agree on.